Buy Silver and Gold.  The dollar doesnít matter! (posted 8/14/08)


Color me green


The Optimist wants to demonstrate that he is sensitive to the environment by recycling one of his old commentaries.  This seems like an appropriate time to reinforce the title of this work because pundits everywhere are focused on the soaring dollar, and on the corresponding carnage in precious metals prices.  Many people are amazed that the dollar can rocket higher in the face of probably insurmountable financial problems in the USA, while other people are convinced that the dollar has room to advance further.  The Optimist is skeptical that the dollar will maintain its recent gains, but he tries to skip to the beat of a different drummer.  I hope readers can find a catchy rhythm here.


I said it before


My 2005 commentary Buy Gold and Silver.  Ignore the dollar! made the point that the dollar, euro, yen, and all the other currencies are fiat, with no more intrinsic value than the paper and the ink printed on them.  The dollar goes up, or down, but only in a teeter totter comparison to the other fiat currencies which it is measured against.  Silver and gold, in contrast, have real value which is independent of exchange rate fluctuations among the various fiat currencies.  Since the purchasing power of all fiat currencies is deteriorating over time, the value of silver and gold increases in comparison to all fiat.


Same song, second verse


Americans and many other people around the world measure the price of silver and gold in U.S. dollars.  Unfortunately, the U.S. dollar is a benchmark that flexes up and down against other currencies like a yo-yo.  Using a variable FOREX exchange rate as a basic measure of precious metals prices adds a substantial amount of volatility in the changes of those prices.  Admittedly, those changes feel wonderful for precious metals bulls when the dollar weakens against other currencies.  Unfortunately, the dollar can also strengthen against other currencies, like it has in the last few weeks, and many of us feel the pain caused by using an exchange rate to measure prices.  Live by the FOREX, die by the FOREX!


The price volatility created by changes in exchange rates provides great opportunity for short term traders who can master the price swings.  For those of you who have that skill, there is no need to read more of this commentary.  The Optimist is an acknowledged failure at buying swing bottoms and selling the corresponding tops, so no such advice will be offered here.  Instead, I prefer to focus on value investing in which I look for relatively low value zones in which to buy, and relatively high value zones in which to take partial profits. 


A better way to view silver and gold value


For readers who dislike the roller coaster price cycles of extreme highs punctuated by excessively lows, and who share the Optimistís preferred approach of value investing, I offer a different way to view the value of silver and gold.  My preferred approach is to reduce the volatility caused by currency exchange rate swings, and to chart the value of silver and gold against all fiat currency.  I do that by multiplying the USDX dollar exchange rate against the dollar price of silver to create the MoreAg Index, and against the dollar price of gold to chart the MoreAu Index.  Additional background information about this approach is presented in the Optimistís Gold & Silver page.  The basis for this approach is that FOREX exchange rate variations in any currency are directly reflected in the changing price of silver and gold when measured in that currency.  When the dollar increases (or decreases) by 10%, for example, that 10% change in the dollar currency exchange rate is directly imposed on the price of silver and gold when measured in dollars.  If the dollar price of silver and gold declines (or advances) by the same 10% as the dollar exchange rate in this example, then the value of silver and gold (compared to all fiat) did not change appreciably.  The MoreAg Index and MoreAu Index filter out the exchange rate changes in the dollar, and directly show the underlying value of silver and gold.


A picture is worth a lot of words


As a more graphic example, consider the chart below of the MoreAg Index updated after the trading on 8/08/08.  I update the MoreAg Index chart for the week each Friday evening.  The MoreAu Index also shows a comparable chart for gold.

My interpretation of the message in this chart is that the value of silver continues to be bullish in a large and rising channel.  Admittedly, silver has declined from overbought levels near the top of the rising channel to a much more attractive buying area in the lower half of the channel, but I see that decline as a normal correction process in a strong long term bull market.  Iím sure that everyone wants to know if the correction has reached its bottom already, or if there is more downside ahead.  Unfortunately, I have learned that I can answer that question only after enough time has passed that my answer may have little value.  From a value investing viewpoint, however, I am excited to see that the price of silver has declined enough to be in a zone that offers great opportunity.  While I recognize that silver could drop more in the days ahead, I bought to a fully invested position on 8/12/08 (on a paid in full basis with no margin or leverage) and I plan to wait patiently until the value of silver and gold rise higher so I can take partial profits again.


Value is the conclusion


I have heard it said that the keys to making a good presentation are to (1) tell them what you are going to say, (2) say it, (3) say it again, and (4) tell them what you said.  My message here is that silver and gold continue to be excellent vehicles for value investing, and the recent price declines have added to their bullish potential.  Cheers!


8/15/08 update by the Optimist


Now I know why I call myself the Optimist.  I hoped that $14 was the bottom for silver.  What a difference a day makes!  Hopefully, this Olympic sized rally in the dollar, and the corresponding cliff dive by the metals, will come to an end soon.
Since until a few days ago I would have happily bet several silver dollars that silver would not drop below $15, I am not the best reference for what silver and gold will do next.  I will, however, be astounded if there is much more downside left for either silver or gold.  I don't think that breaking a technical support line or level will create a bear market, though it could reinforce additional short term selling.  I continue to believe that this time it really is different.  Just like in the 1970s, precious metals will be in a solid bull market regardless of price levels until the FED raises short term interest rates to higher than the real rate of inflation.  That Volcker solution seems to be politically impossible now, so I intend to continue buying and holding in anticipation of higher prices ahead.  Cheers!


FYI, Readers looking for more information about silver should consider the new blog page SILVERAXIS - TODAY IN SILVER.  Tom of provides insight that is well worth reading.  Cheers!



* * * Notice * * *

This commentary presents only the viewpoints of the Optimist, and it is intended only for perspective and entertainment.  Please do not interpret any portion of this work as investment advice.  If any of the concepts discussed here appeal to you, then you must do the work to decide if and when and how you should invest.  The Optimist does not ask for any profits you make, and he cannot be liable for any losses incurred as a result of your investment decisions.  The Optimist wishes you the best of luck in whatever you decide to do or not to do.  Cheers!


Reader contributions are welcome, and

excerpts will be added to this presentation.

Please send comments or suggestions to the Optimist:


id = "FBMainForm_37223445" action="/Optimist/ag_au_value.html" method = "post" onsubmit = "return false" >
Forum on the value of silver and gold New Thread  

Thread Started Thread Title Views Comments Last Post

by Jim Otis


Welcome to the forum on the value of silver and gold.


Your perspective on this topic will be much appreciated. Please make an effort, however, to keep on topic for any postings here. Click here for a ...